Billboards are here to stay, city says

[ErickMontreal]

Billboards are here to stay, city says

A proposed bylaw in provincial capital would ban the signs from its territory

JAMES MENNIE, The Gazette

Published: 6 hours ago

Billboards may become a thing of the past in Quebec City by 2013, but there's no indication it will also happen in Montreal.

 

"The city (of Montreal) has no intention of following suit," city hall spokesperson Darren Becker said, referring to public hearings in Quebec City about whether a total ban on billboards there should go into effect in five years.

 

"We did ask for a review of the trucks that pull billboards down city streets, but no more than that," Becker said.

A billboard greets motorists arriving in Montreal via the Bonaventure Expressway. Quebec City is considering outlawing such advertisements.View Larger Image View Larger Image

A billboard greets motorists arriving in Montreal via the Bonaventure Expressway. Quebec City is considering outlawing such advertisements.

 

His comments follow reports of a growing wave of corporate criticism of a proposed bylaw in Quebec City that would make it illegal to erect a billboard within its territory.

 

City officials in the provincial capital have defended the law by stating that the architecture and scenic beauty of their municipality shouldn't be hidden behind advertising.

 

Public hearings are being held to debate the bylaw, which the municipality hopes to adopt by the end of this year and put into effect by 2013.

 

However the aesthetic argument doesn't hold water with corporations and companies that rely on billboard advertising for revenue.

 

Billboard companies have already described the bylaw as discriminatory, and suggested they might seek damages from the city for lost revenue.

 

More recently, oil companies have argued that removing the sign panels that advertise pump prices for gasoline at their service stations might not only result in customers being overcharged for gas, but also represent a possible danger to motorists in need of assistance who would no longer be able to see gas stations from a distance.

 

However, Serge Viau, Quebec City's deputy general manager, said the days of billboards are already coming to an end in his municipality.

 

Some former suburbs banned the advertising before being transformed into Quebec City boroughs, Viau said.

 

"We already had the power to eliminate billboards written into our charter," he said. "And we did so; a few years ago we got rid of about 20 of them in downtown Quebec.

 

"And Ste. Foy, when it was still a municipality, had a total ban on billboards."

 

Viau said the latest ban would be total - even on public service messages produced by the provincial government.

 

Viau said all of the city's boroughs were in favour of a total ban, rather than limiting them to particular parts of the city, such as industrial zones.

 

The approach of trying to limit the presence of billboards to certain parts of town was tried by the city of Oakville, Ont., which adopted a bylaw in 2005 ordering billboards only be permitted in industrial zones.

 

The bylaw was adopted after an attempt at a total ban was struck down on constitutional grounds.

 

However, in February, that bylaw was also struck down in Ontario Superior Court, the judge ruling that the Charter of Rights and Freedoms protected virtually all forms of communication.

 

The city has decided to appeal that ruling.

 

jmennie@thegazette.canwest.com

[Habsfan]

What's wrong with Billboards? I don't have a problem with them!

[jesseps]

interesting.

 

one thing N.A doesn't have a huge problem with billboards like eastern europe, now thats insane and a sight for sore eyes

[JCC-Fromthere]

What about Nathan Road, in Hong Kong... very cool to walk around there

 

http://www.worldofstock.com/slides/TAO1469.jpg

http://www.12hk.com/area/TST/TST_NathanRoad_IMG_0592_w600.jpg

http://www.12hk.com/area/Mongkok/NathanRoad_IMG_5647.jpg

 

City wide it would be a nightmare, but in a few spots, it's actually pretty neat IMHO.