Is America's suburban dream collapsing into a nightmare?

[ErickMontreal]

Is America's suburban dream collapsing into a nightmare?

 

Suburban neighborhoods are becoming refuges for those outpriced in gentrifying inner-cities.

 

By Lara Farrar

For CNN

 

(CNN) -- When Shaun Yandell proposed to his longtime girlfriend Gina Marasco on the doorstep of their new home in the sunny suburb of Elk Grove, California, four years ago, he never imagined things would get this bad. But they did, and it happened almost overnight.

art.jpg

 

"It is going to be heartbreak," Yandell told CNN. "But we are hanging on."

 

Yandell's marriage isn't falling apart: his neighborhood is.

 

Devastated by the subprime mortgage crisis, hundreds of homes have been foreclosed and thousands of residents have been forced to move, leaving in their wake a not-so-pleasant path of empty houses, unkempt lawns, vacant strip malls, graffiti-sprayed desolate sidewalks and even increased crime.

 

In Elk Grove, some homeowners not only cut their own grass but also trim the yards of vacant homes on their streets, hoping to deter gangs and criminals from moving in.

 

Other residents discovered that with some of the empty houses, it wasn't what was growing outside that was the problem. Susan McDonald, president of a local neighborhood association aimed at saving the lost suburban paradise, told CNN that around her cul-de-sac, federal agents recently busted several pot homes with vast crops of marijuana growing from floor to ceiling.

 

And only a couple of weeks ago, Yandell said he overheard a group of teenagers gathered on the street outside his back patio, talking about a robbery they had just committed.

 

When they lit a street sign on fire, Yandell called the cops.

 

"This is not like a rare thing anymore," he said. "I get big congregations of people cussing -- stuff I can't even fathom doing when I was a kid."

Don't Miss

 

For Yandell, his wife and many other residents trying to stick it out, the white picket fence of an American dream has faded into a seemingly hopeless suburban nightmare. "The forecast is gloomy," he told CNN.

 

While the foreclosure epidemic has left communities across the United States overrun with unoccupied houses and overgrown grass, underneath the chaos another trend is quietly emerging that, over the next several decades, could change the face of suburban American life as we know it.

 

This trend, according to Christopher Leinberger, an urban planning professor at the University of Michigan and visiting fellow at the Brookings Institution, stems not only from changing demographics but also from a major shift in the way an increasing number of Americans -- especially younger generations -- want to live and work.

 

"The American dream is absolutely changing," he told CNN.

 

This change can be witnessed in places like Atlanta, Georgia, Detroit, Michigan, and Dallas, Texas, said Leinberger, where once rundown downtowns are being revitalized by well-educated, young professionals who have no desire to live in a detached single family home typical of a suburbia where life is often centered around long commutes and cars.

 

Instead, they are looking for what Leinberger calls "walkable urbanism" -- both small communities and big cities characterized by efficient mass transit systems and high density developments enabling residents to walk virtually everywhere for everything -- from home to work to restaurants to movie theaters.

 

The so-called New Urbanism movement emerged in the mid-90s and has been steadily gaining momentum, especially with rising energy costs, environmental concerns and health problems associated with what Leinberger calls "drivable suburbanism" -- a low-density built environment plan that emerged around the end of the World War II and has been the dominant design in the U.S. ever since.

 

Thirty-five percent of the nation's wealth, according to Leinberger, has been invested in constructing this drivable suburban landscape.

 

But now, Leinberger told CNN, it appears the pendulum is beginning to swing back in favor of the type of walkable community that existed long before the advent of the once fashionable suburbs in the 1940s. He says it is being driven by generations molded by television shows like "Seinfeld" and "Friends," where city life is shown as being cool again -- a thing to flock to, rather than flee.

 

"The image of the city was once something to be left behind," said Leinberger.

 

Changing demographics are also fueling new demands as the number of households with children continues to decline. By the end of the next decade, the number of single-person households in the United States will almost equal those with kids, Leinberger said.

 

And aging baby boomers are looking for a more urban lifestyle as they downsize from large homes in the suburbs to more compact town houses in more densely built locations.

 

Recent market research indicates that up to 40 percent of households surveyed in selected metropolitan areas want to live in walkable urban areas, said Leinberger. The desire is also substantiated by real estate prices for urban residential space, which are 40 to 200 percent higher than in traditional suburban neighborhoods -- this price variation can be found both in cities and small communities equipped with walkable infrastructure, he said.

 

The result is an oversupply of depreciating suburban housing and a pent-up demand for walkable urban space, which is unlikely to be met for a number of years. That's mainly, according to Leinberger, because the built environment changes very slowly; and also because governmental policies and zoning laws are largely prohibitive to the construction of complicated high-density developments.

 

But as the market catches up to the demand for more mixed use communities, the United States could see a notable structural transformation in the way its population lives -- Arthur C. Nelson, director of Virginia Tech's Metropolitan Institute, estimates, for example, that half of the real-estate development built by 2025 will not have existed in 2000.

 

Yet Nelson also estimates that in 2025 there will be a surplus of 22 million large-lot homes that will not be left vacant in a suburban wasteland but instead occupied by lower classes who have been driven out of their once affordable inner-city apartments and houses.

 

The so-called McMansion, he said, will become the new multi-family home for the poor.

 

"What is going to happen is lower and lower-middle income families squeezed out of downtown and glamorous suburban locations are going to be pushed economically into these McMansions at the suburban fringe," said Nelson. "There will probably be 10 people living in one house."

 

In Shaun Yandell's neighborhood, this has already started to happen. Houses once filled with single families are now rented out by low-income tenants. Yandell speculates that they're coming from nearby Sacramento, where the downtown is undergoing substantial gentrification, or perhaps from some other area where prices have gotten too high. He isn't really sure.

 

But one thing Yandell is sure about is that he isn't going to leave his sunny suburban neighborhood unless he has to, and if that happens, he says he would only want to move to another one just like it.

 

"It's the American dream, you know," he said. "The American dream."

 

http://www.cnn.com/2008/TECH/06/16/suburb.city/index.html

 

[cjb]

Très intéressant comme article, il parle d'une dynamique déjà en marche depuis plusieurs années. Même si pour certains la banlieue reste encore ce rêve de style de vie de plus en plus controversé, de plus en plus de gens le remettent en question.

Le phénomène est très présent au Québec, même si les banlieues restent encore très attractive. Tous les lofts et condos bâtis au centre-ville depuis 10 ans confirme tout de même cette tendance.

 

Lorsque les baby-boomers mourront massivement d'ici une vingtaine d'années, des rues entières de Laval ou de Longueuil pourraient devenir des ghost towns.

Le courrier de Laval parlait de cette tendance il y a quelques mois,

[Malek]

La tendance de quoi ? Que la population de l'île de montréal est encore stagnante ? pendant que la couronne grandit?

 

13% des gens qui déménagent à Montréal cette année quittent l'île, c'est pas rien.

 

Les petits lofts ou condos batis au centre ville, et ils sont tous vides... ne contenant qu'une personne, les familles ayant déjà quittés.

[cjb]

J'avoue qu'au Québec la mentalité banlieue est encore très forte.

[Malek]

Honnêtement, Montréal, ses banlieus sont pas trop loin, en tout cas la grande majorité.

 

J'ai toujours de la misère avec les banlieux à la hauteur de st-jérome, ça commence à faire loin en tab****... mais c'est rien comparée aux banlieux aux USA.

 

On les apelle là bas les extreme commuters, pour donner une idée, ça sera comme si qqun partait de ste-agathe des monts, ou plus au nord pour venir travailler a montréal à chaque jour!

[cjb]

Je travaille au centre-ville avec du monde de Sorel et de Berthierville... Faut le faire.

[Malek]

Y en avait un à la SQ qui était a Sainte Adèle! À sa décharge c'était un vieu bonhomme qui allait prendre sa retraite dans quelques années, il s'était trouvé une maison/chalet au bord de l'eau et était prêt à endurer.

 

Y a un gars maintenant qui fait le train pendant une heure et demie+ 30 de bus! WTF.

[Habsfan]

Il y a des américains qui ntraversent la frontière tous les jours pour venir travailler en ville. Ils viennent surtout du Vermont et Up-State New-York.

[yarabundi]

Il y a des américains qui ntraversent la frontière tous les jours pour venir travailler en ville. Ils viennent surtout du Vermont et Up-State New-York.

Tu te fous de notre gueule ? Est-ce vraiment possible ??

[champdemars]

Honnêtement, Montréal, ses banlieus sont pas trop loin, en tout cas la grande majorité.

 

J'ai toujours de la misère avec les banlieux à la hauteur de st-jérome, ça commence à faire loin en tab****... mais c'est rien comparée aux banlieux aux USA.

 

On les apelle là bas les extreme commuters, pour donner une idée, ça sera comme si qqun partait de ste-agathe des monts, ou plus au nord pour venir travailler a montréal à chaque jour!

 

Il y avait un gars qui travaillait dans mon bureau il y a 5 ans qui habitait Ste-Agathe-des-Monts! Il doit travailler encore au bureau, mais j'ai changé de bâtisse, alors je ne peux confirmer.

 

Un autre freak: Un gestionnaire de projets que j'ai connu habitait à Magog et venait à Montréal chaque matin...

 

Le dernier cas habite à St-Félix-de-Valois.