Recommended Posts

36 minutes ago, Davidbourque said:

Je me demande si le métro de Montréal a un système d'aiguillage assez intelligent pour gérer 2 branche. Si oui, alors un axe vers Montréal nord pourrais être intéressant. 

Mais bon c'est très hypothétique. 

Il ne s'agirait pas du métro de Montréal mais du REM de la ligne rose.  Pour la gestion de deux branches, les 3 quais à Henri-Bourassa en font d'office.

Partager ce message

Lien à poster
Partager sur d’autres sites

Cependant, à Henri Bourrassa, on injecte une rame entre 2 rame provenant de Laval. Tandis qu'ici, on parle d'une rame qui suivrait son propre trajets et qu'il faudra faire arriver au bon moment. Je parle bien sur en ayant une expérience utilisateurs agréable. S'il faut attendre dans le tunnel quelques temps à chaque fois, ça ne le fera pas. Avec le REM, ça sera complètement transparent. 


Partager ce message

Lien à poster
Partager sur d’autres sites

Beaucoup de commantaire interressant sur un post /r/montreal sur le pink line:


Argument particulierment interressant c'est que le estima de cout du pink line est en fait sur-estimee.


C'est particulierement etonnant que si ca couterai le meme par km que l'extension laval, le pink line serai ~$3 milliard.


Pourquoi est ce que $6 milliard semble pas realiste pour du monde? Ce lien liste le prix par km de pleins de project metro. La majorite sont beaucoup moins chere que le proposition ici:


Modifié par gelu88

Partager ce message

Lien à poster
Partager sur d’autres sites

Projet Montréal's Pink line: Pipe dream or election game-changer? 

A closer look at just how realistic is Valérie Plante's plan to build a new Metro line

By Jonathan Montpetit, CBC News Posted: Oct 12, 2017 8:00 PM ET Last Updated: Oct 12, 2017 9:13 PM ET


As the underdog in the race for city hall, Projet Montréal needed a proposal that could grab the public's attention and swing votes its way. 

The party's proposed Pink line expansion to the Metro system, announced earlier this week, grabbed everyone's attention, all right. Whether it can accomplish the second goal will depend on how realistic Montrealers believe the project to be.

Denis Coderre, who is seeking a second term as mayor, abruptly dismissed the idea of building a new Metro line that would cut diagonally across the city and consist of 29 stations.

"You have to be realistic. The Just for Laughs Festival is over," he told reporters Wednesday in Pierrefonds. "We know it won't work, so why entertain false hopes?"

However, engineering and public policy experts consulted by CBC News offer a more nuanced analysis of the proposal to build a 29-kilometre Metro line from Montreal North to Lachine.

On the one hand, they acknowledge the line meets a need, and financing is available. On the other hand, they believe Projet's estimated price-tag of $6 billion and its six-year timeline might be overly optimistic.

The route

Projet Montréal has made appealing to the "sardine class" — its way of referring to cramped Metro commuters — a priority of its campaign. And the Pink line, it says, will alleviate some of the demand on the city's other subway lines.

"We clearly, right now, still have a deficit in public transportation in Montreal," said Gérard Mounier, a strategic advisor specializing in infrastructure and project financing for the law firm Lavery. "Everyone is agreed that the Orange line is saturated."

The Pink line, as it's currently sketched out, is designed to travel through some of the densest neighbourhoods in the city, giving them more rapid access to the downtown core.

Normally that would give rise to concerns about disruption to businesses and residents during construction. But Projet's proposal banks on new engineering technology — a tunnel-boring machine — that digs pathways deep underground.

TBMs, as they're known in the industry, have allowed a number of cities in Europe and North America to undertake complicated infrastructure projects without getting bogged down in costly expropriations, rewiring electrical grids and digging up sewer systems. 

"Tunnel-boring machines are potentially more efficient and can minimize disruption in some ways, but they're not a magic bullet solution," said Matti Siemiatycki, a geography and planning professor at the University of Toronto. 

Because the machines operate deep underground and are difficult to access, technical problems can mean costly and lengthy delays, said Siemiatycki, who recently wrote a paper on cost overruns in public infrastructure projects. 

The financing

That raises the question of Projet's proposed $6 billion budget.

When the party announced the Pink line earlier this week, it mentioned three potential sources of funding: the new federal infrastructure bank, the federal public transit infrastructure fund and a provincial infrastructure fund. 

These funds reflect the willingness of both Quebec and Ottawa to fork out cash for big infrastructure projects, and that should hearten the project's supporters. 

"There is a  a massive amount of capital available in Canada to finance any large-scale transportation project," said Mounier.

But although Projet has stated its preference for the Pink line to be entirely publicly funded, it may not have the choice if the infrastructure bank is involved.

Ottawa envisions the bank, which is not yet fully operational, being used to leverage private investment in public projects. Private investors are likely to want to recoup their investments through real estate developments along the Metro line.

"I really think that Projet Montréal ... is going to have to be candid about the fact that there is going to need to be development on these stations, and beside these stations, in a way that generates ... commercial income for the private partners," said Brian Kelcey, founder the urban affairs think-tank, State of the City.   

Budget and timeline

It is, arguably, the ability to bring a large infrastructure project in on time and on budget that has Montrealers most skeptical. 

The five-kilometre extension of the Metro's Orange line to Laval ended up costing $745 million, hundreds of millions more than initial estimates. 

That project, however, didn't make use of TBM technology, which has dramatically altered the infrastructure calculus. 

Madrid and Barcelona have used TBMs to complete projects in less time and for less money than Projet has budgeted for the Pink line, said Kelcey, a former adviser to Ontario's Ministry of Transportation.

But using European models ignores the different culture and context of infrastructure construction in Canada.  

"In North America ... and Canada in particular, we're lousy at containing costs for subway and transit construction. We're lousy at building quickly," he said. 

Projet's costing, moreover, may be on the ambitious side. In Europe and North America, the price range for subway projects is between $300 million and $500 million per kilometre.

If the Pink line comes in at the low end of that range, that's still $2.7 billion more than the figure Projet is circulating. 

"Six billion dollars is a lot of money, don't get me wrong," said Jean Habimana, who heads the tunneling group in the Montreal office of Hatch, an engineering consulting firm. 

"But in the grand scheme of things, if you're talking about 30 kilometres, it may not be enough."éal-s-pink-line-pipe-dream-or-election-game-changer-1.4351876

Partager ce message

Lien à poster
Partager sur d’autres sites

Créer un compte ou se connecter pour commenter

Vous devez être membre afin de pouvoir déposer un commentaire

Créer un compte

Créez un compte sur notre communauté. C’est facile !

Créer un nouveau compte

Se connecter

Vous avez déjà un compte ? Connectez-vous ici.

Connectez-vous maintenant

  • Contenu similaire

    • Par Feanaro
      Source :
    • Par nephersir7
      J'ai trouvé le le sommaire de l'étude qui a recommandé en 2016 de ne pas aller de l'avant:

    • Par IluvMTL
      Article dans La Presse+ autour des problèmes de criminalité dans le parc. Ils vont refaire l'édicule du Métro Atwater, mais certains veulent l'énlever complètement.
      Sent from my SM-T330NU using Tapatalk
    • Par IluvMTL
      Via Coolopolis on Facebook
      Condo buyers propel expansion of Montreal's underground city: what to expect next      What sane person would want to live with screaming hockey fans and rock concert scalpers outside their window?
         Many wondered just that when condos at the Bell Centre went on sale.
         But not only were the units snapped up quickly, they sold at a price far higher than others in the area.
         The difference between those units and others in nearby Griffintown or at Mountain and Dorch?
         The Bell Centre is connected to the underground city, Montreal's downtown pedestrian network.
          Condo shoppers have voted with their dollars and they want a home that permits them to stroll to their cubicle at Place Ville Marie without donning a sweater, jacket, raincoat or long undies.
          Red lights, smog, slush, icy sidewalks, puddles, cold winds, rain, snow and sleet be damned!
          People want to walk in climate-controlled, safely to one's destinations past countless shiny boutiques en route.
         Now that consumers have proven that they want to live downtown connected to the underground city, expect the floodgates to open.
           So where will the next tunnels migrate? Presumably the tunnels are already headed under St. Antoine Street in the upcoming development across from the Bell Centre, so that will likely expand the ant farm south.    The showers in the Canadiens
      Towers aren't its big attraction     But the those who know the invisible mood borders of downtown understand why Peel and St. Catherine is not only downtown's signature intersection, but it's also a border from the smaller structures to the west to the big boys east.
         Peel and St. Catherine is where the underground city needs its grand entrance.
         One would be able to enter around the recently-closed HMV record shop at the southeast corner.
         The tunnel would slip diagonally to another famous structure, the Sun Life building, which really needs to be represented in this tunneltastic undertaking.
          The tunnel from the Sun Life would go diagonally to Central Station, with another foot tunnel going east to the building across Metcalfe and then onto Place Ville Marie.
           For years the underground city was plagued by a lack of connection under St. Catherine Street. It's time to get another one going as well and Peel and St. Catherine would be just the place to do it.
           Expanding such networks would come cost for construction, maintenance and security surveillance but those expenses could be more than compensated by increased revenues from residential construction, thereby increasing the residential density of the downtown area.
        Another oft-overlooked underground tunnel network has been a cash cow, not for Montreal but for  Westmount, as the Alexis Nihon / Westmount Square network has recognized from the start that home dwellers want to get in on the tunnel action.
         That tunnel system now travels from Green all the way to the southeast corner of Atwater and St. Catherine. Now a major new project is slated at the site of the former Children's Hospital and yeah, that's just a stone's toss away from a tunnel at Cabot Square.
         Extending that tunnel under Cabot Square to the development would create another substantial underground city.
          The old Montreal Forum will inevitably be demolished or redesigned and another tower at the southwest corner of St. Catherine and Atwater would give some impressive critical mass to that area and the building at that stands where the Seville Theatre long thrilled moviegoers, could also be connected to the underground.
        The area has become a hub of activity, as all those rebel kids of Bill 101 have jammed Dawson College CEGEP to finally get an English education.
        Increased development at Atwater and St. Catherine is a cause all can support, as it would rejuvenate the long-beleaguered stretch of St. Catherine to Guy, where street commerce has long suffered from a lack of population density on the western edge of the strip.
         Construction at St. Lawrence and De Maisonneuve is also inevitable, as the southwest corner is already being built. A project has long been slated for the St. Lawrence metro station but has yet to happen. Those projects, when they materialize, could get hooked up with the Place des Arts tunnel system. The massive, sprawling and dubious Jeanne Mance public housing project, which - unless redesigned - remains an obstacle to further tunnel development to the east of the Main.
      And finally the Vendome metro superhospital has become a sort of tiny newborn tunnel network but it has yet to make that push  beyond its narrow facility. The nearby busy intersection of De Maisonneuve and Decarie offers considerable potential for office or condo tower or commercial development, as thousands of staffers would love a way to live nearby. That in turn could be linked into a new network of tunnels.
        Posted Yesterday by Kristian Gravenor Labels: bell centre Bell Centre condos Cours Mont Royal montreal condos montreal development Place Ville Marie pvm reso Sun Life Building underground city  
    • Par denpanosekai